Alistair and Cailan: Two Sides of a Prior King
May 11
The Last Three Heirs to the Theirin Dynasty Are Ultimately the Same Man
Minor Spoilers in this article. Read on only if you already know all there is to know about Prince Maric, Alistair and King Cailan.
Maric, before he became King of Ferelden, was a rebel prince and sometime reluctant leader to the forces fighting against the occupying empire of Orlais. In the Dragon Age prequel novel, The Stolen Throne, we see Prince Maric as both a naive and emotional boy with much charm and good humour, and as a somewhat bitter and practical man willing to do what needs to be done to free his people and secure his throne. In Dragon Age: Origins, we find Maric’s two sons – one of whom never knew him – both showing aspects of the distinctive character that defined Maric the prince.
King Cailan
Prince Maric, before the death of his mother, the Rebel Queen, and his subsequent growth and rise to his duty, had a somewhat wide-eyed and naive world view. While he was often more than he was perceived by others, he could be described as a bit of a royal brat, far too wrapped up in his own life, wants and station to notice more than his immediate surroundings. This is no small feat considering he was raised in a traveling war camp in occupied territory. Regardless, he was boyish in nature, excitable and curious, and flippant when it came to his duty. This was a well educated young man, enthralled by thoughts of adventure, but knowing nothing of the world beyond his doorstep. Charming, though. Very charming.
When we meet King Cailan in Dragon Age: Origins, he is, in many ways, the same person. About to enter a major battle with the Darkspawn, Cailan is ever the impetuous young lord, wanting to experience the world’s darker and different elements because he finds them ‘neat’. Battles are glorious to Cailan – especially battles fought alongside legends like the Grey Wardens – even facing ridiculous odds, he was still excited and supremely confident. Unfortunately things didn’t work out quite how he had pictured them…
King Cailan was not a bad King, nor was Maric a bad Prince, and both did have a practical side (as Cailan showed when he angered more than a few powerful people in Ferelden when he suggested reaching out to their former conquerors, Orlais, for aid). Neither he nor the young Prince Maric could be truly called idiots, but both wore their naiveté and child’s eyes for all to see, which often made them look the fool.
Alistair
Alistair was the truly down to earth, ‘i don’t want any part of being royalty’ guy. This was something that Prince Maric nurtured, as well – until his heart was crushed. Loghain, his best friend, helped to drive Maric from a fun-loving, boyish man, into a practical leader who could close off his heart and his idealist virtues enough to mete out justice and vengeance on his enemies. This wore heavy on his heart and killed his innocence, quieting the boy in him, but he drove forward due to his intense commitment to his duty.
Alistair’s life was not an easy one. He was not acknowledged by his father as he was a potentially major royal problem and embarrassment (being that he was the product of a dalliance, and there was already an heir to the throne in Cailan). He was raised hard by Arl Eamon and given to the Chantry to become a Templar – a life he did not want, and did not truly believe in. These things engendered a more, shall we say, sardonic nature in Alistair…
Like Maric, Alistair was blessed with a quick tongue and a sharp sense of humour – but this was not a man who could be considered as naive or foolish. Insecure and self-deprecating, yes – but more in tune to the ‘realistic’ aspects of human nature. Alistair, like Prince Maric in his latter days, before he claimed the crown, is capable of doing ‘what needs to be done’, even if the cost is high and the morality ambiguous. He has lines that he will not cross – but even those will be stepped over on occasion if the situation calls for it, though with a heavy heart and a ding in his spirit.
Alistair is who Maric became on the death of his love, Katriel, and who Maric might have been sooner had Maric’s mother, the Rebel Queen, died when he was a young boy. The Rebel Queen’s death, in its own time, created a duty for Maric that tempered his attitudes, but the breaking of his heart and Loghain’s manipulations are what drove him to end his own innocence – though he never seemed to adopt the long term cynicism that marks Alistair. Ultimately however, all three characters – Prince Maric, King Calilan, and Alistair – truly seem to be the same person, just reacting to different circumstances. Maric was wide-eyed, with a naive world view, a sharp wit and ‘unending charm’. His sense of duty and practicality, as well as his loss of innocence helped him to grow and change into a strong king, with a heavy heart. Additionally, there was one constant that held for all three men, regardless of circumstance: the inability to keep their mouths shut for extended periods of time. Except when brooding, of course.
What are your thoughts on the last three heairs of the Theirin dynasty, the blood of Calenhad the Great, first king of Ferelden?
Liked the article? Support us so we can bring you even more high quality content.
















13 comments
Comment by chilyn on May 11, 2010 at 10:14 pm
Thanks Maria13! Alistair is definitely the one with whom we are the most familiar, and I find the character of Maric interesting, but rushed. However, I would argue that Maric is actually a much better fighter than he thinks he is (and we are most often given his own perception of his fighting prowess in comparison to others in the books) — but it is definitely hard to compare to the juggernauts the characters can become in game. And while Maric started out as a brat, he develops into a hardworking, duty-bound man — err, King.
Comment by Maria13 on May 11, 2010 at 9:26 pm
Interesting article. I think overall Alistair is the most complete of the three, whereas Cailan mostly due to his privileged upbringing is the slightest. Alistair, like Maric he has had to endure adversity from a young age and gets to mix with "real" people. Unlike Maric, who seems to rely on luck and a magic sword quite a lot, he is an extremely well trained fighter spanning different disciplines and by the end of the game has acquired almost unrivalled practical combat experience against a variety of opponents. Finally, Alistair unlike either Maric or Cailan who are both somewhat indolent, seems to have a predisposition for honest hard work.
Comment by Khazarkhum on May 12, 2010 at 8:11 am
We aren't around Cailan enough to really see what's going on under the surface; we have to piece that together later, and we end up with a very different image than we started with.
Cailan falls into the tradition of the charismatic young king who plays dumb as a way to flush out who he can & can't trust. That he's negotiating with Orlais himself is proof of that: he knows he can't trust anyone else with it. Loghain is clearly working to isolate him from his strongest supporters, which can only mean that Loghain has been planning a coup for some time–and Cailan knows about it. No wonder he wants to be surrounded by Grey Wardens.
Comment by Maria13 on May 12, 2010 at 4:37 pm
Hi Chilyn I admit I am an adoring Alistairian and therefore probably quite biased. I feel deeply out of love with Maric when he slew Katriel an act of cowardice if ever I've seen one, however, I agree that Maric systematically underestimates himself as a warrior as does unhardened Alistair and probably also Cailan, though as Khazar remarks above, we only get the merest glimpse of Cailan… Great to talk.
Comment by chilyn on May 12, 2010 at 11:45 pm
I totally agree on the Maric/Katriel ending — as I mentioned in my Stolen Throne review last week, there was a part where I nearly set the book on fire… that was it. It seemed entirely out of character, at least for his current level of development.
Comment by chilyn on May 12, 2010 at 11:48 pm
True, we aren't around him very long — but long enough to get a feel for how he was perceived and for his character. As I mentioned in the article, he was not a bad king, nor was he stupid — but he clearly appears to be somewhat… over-excitable?
Comment by Godzilla Guru on May 13, 2010 at 6:10 am
I know this first half of my comment has almost nothing to do with the article, but this makes me hate Loghain all over again. I mean I can understand some of his reasons and for a time I can almost forgive him enough to see the logic in recruiting him (after hardening Allistar so he can still be king), but reading this article and remembering what he did to his own friend just makes me want to take a Keening Blade and run it through him all over again! As for Allistar and Cailan, I think the fact of the matter is they were both needed for Fereldan at the appropriate times. Cailan may or may not have had the best idea in stopping the Blight, but he knew he had to do SOMETHING to keep it from advancing unchecked. Allistar seemed to do just fine once he became king (with or without Anora), and your article confirms what I suspected of him (though your wording is better than I would have put it).
Comment by chilyn on May 13, 2010 at 11:29 pm
I hear you man. Loghain is an interesting personality — bit of a sociopath in his commitment to what he views as right and wrong and within the realms of duty. Whole other article, that guy! O.0 I found his choices very frustrating at times, but he was probably the easiest character in the book to understand, insofar as motivations are concerned. He didn't want to do what he did to Maric — he was following his friend's wishes to the letter, doing what he thought was his duty as a friend and as a dutiful citizen of the realm. Troubling thing is, in many ways he was right, but his methods left much to be desired.
I think Cailan did try to do something and saw a threat, yes — but it sure seemed like the guy was more enraptured with the thought of glory and didn't see the threat for what it truly was either. And I have nothing but sympathy for Alistair. All he wanted was a normal life. The fact that he doesn't want to be king combined with his sense of duty makes for a good king, though. (generally)
Comment by Khazarkhum on May 14, 2010 at 5:51 am
Enthusiastic is the better word. He's an enthusiast.
What happens in-game is that we initially see him the way we're supposed to perceive him–which means, for all practical purposes, what Loghain thinks. It's only in RTO that we realize we missed a great deal.
Comment by Khazarkhum on May 14, 2010 at 5:52 am
Why Loghain is allowed to live after that is a mystery. The man harbors nothing but hate.
Comment by Khazarkhum on May 14, 2010 at 6:19 am
As rulers Cailan & Maric both have to contend with Loghain, whereas it is possible for Alistair to eliminate him. By the end of Origins Loghain's coup is out in the open, his willingness to destroy Ferelden is clear, and everyone knows he must be stopped if there is any hope of surviving the Blight.
Maric, however, is too in awe, perhaps even too afraid, of Loghain to deal with him effectively. He does not heed Flemeth's warning about Loghain's betrayals. We all know how well that turns out.
Cailan has to pay the price for keeping Loghain around. By the time we see him he knows Loghain is planning a coup. It's hinted at in Eamon's letter: why would a child be needed to 'unite' Ferelden unless Loghain was actively creating discord? Loghain wants the throne; he feels he deserves that thone; and if he has to kill his way there, he will do it. Cailan caught on, took steps to stop him, and unfortunately for him Loghain found out.
Comment by nnylarac on May 21, 2010 at 9:43 pm
Chilyn writes in regards to character of the three men not the deeds of their lives. Whether they accomplished this or that does not describe their character. I completely agree however in much of this article. Their characters are surprisingly similar and I am pretty sure that was intended by the writers. The only difference that Cailan seems to have is based off of the heroism he saw in his father and the influence of books about his father's life on his own. We really only get to see his overconfidence that all three people had in their story lines. Maric did not grow up in a castle and it was at the time up in the air whether or not they would ever get a castle back to rule in so he was not pressured to be a king until later in the story. I am constantly wondering however how Goldanna fits in all of this; lore versus game content. Technically is not Allistar the son of Fiona? In the end of the book she presents a baby to the king, to which they hide yes? This would make sense yet this does not fit right with the story line in the game. Who is Goldanna and is she a possible line of string to make the story more curious? Plus she's human, so where does this maid fit in and is it some elaborate cover story just in case someone asked? I really hope they write a new book.
Comment by trinity on May 23, 2010 at 2:37 am
Loghain. As a matter of fact I disliked the character so much I almost past-up a great book because he was one of the main characters in it. THE STOLEN THRONE- with this book you couldn't help but like (Not Love) Loghain. But with the second book THE CALLING to me this when loghain started showing his true colors (Not as bold as in the game but to me there were signs of what was to come with him). You may or may not have read these two books so I will not say anything else about them.