Fate’s Plaything: Jowan – Part Two
Jun 21
The Desperate Apostate.
“Am I not allowed to have regrets?” - Jowan
Welcome to Part Two of this feature on Jowan. If you missed last week’s installment, you can read it HERE
The Mage Origin is critical for better understanding Jowan. The first time I came around the Redcliffe Dungeon, all I knew was that he’s a blood mage and that he may or may not be responsible for the horrors taking place in town. But as the trusting Grey Warden Cousland I was, I believed he wanted to help and let him out to assist me. Little did I know then I was sealing his fate.
But with the proper background, the next time I saw Jowan locked up in that dungeon, I felt pity that his life had gone so wrong up to that point. The tragedy of his life was something was something I was sure I wanted to fix – so much to even fix his code-broken path to redemption.
The Traitorous Tutor
After his narrow and daring escape from the Circle Tower and now branded as a blood mage apostate, Jowan was on the run, desperate to find salvation from his predicament. Although the templars no longer had his phylactery to track him with, that didn’t necessarily mean he was safe from their hunting.
By a stroke of, what appeared to be luck at the time, Jowan gets connected with Teryn Loghain, who offers him a glimmer of hope to solve his serious problems. Lady Isolde of Redcliffe happens to be looking for an apostate to train her mage son, so that he might not be collected by the templars and taken to a life forever cooped into the Circle Tower. And with Arl Eamon being a political enemy for Loghain in his machinations to usurp/save Ferelden, the opportunity arises for the Teryn to send Jowan in as an agent under the pretense of the tutor but with the plan to eliminate a major player in Ferelden’s structue of nobility. If Jowan can accomplish the deed, Loghain promises to do what he can to help Jowan live free.
To Jowan, this path, although paved over the grave of Arl Eamon, must sound too good to pass up. As he tells the Warden, why wouldn’t he trust Teryn Loghain, the hero of Ferelden? And especially when the Teryn understands Jowan’s plight and offers (perhaps falsely, perhaps not) to help, how could Jowan refuse?
The situation poses a moral questions of sorts – would you kill someone else to save yourself? A majority of people might argue no. But, combine that question with Loghain’s deception that Arl Eamon is a serious, imminent threat to Ferelden’s safety, and you’ve created somewhat of a ticking timebomb scenario. Should Jowan kill Arl Eamon to spare other lives that might be lost in civil war? Add the cherry on top that Loghain will help Jowan with his whole blood-mage-apostate issue and the scenario can actually to sound like the right thing to do.
And so he takes that path and poisons the Arl. But nothing ever is simple for Jowan, and of course, everything goes wrong.
The Scapegoat
Jowan poisons the Arl but obviously isn’t too discreet about it and gets caught. And soon enough, people start dying and the castle starts spewing out walking corpses every night into Redcliffe village. Lady Isolde, naturally turns her wrath on him as the cause.
This is where blame games gets complicated. Technically, the whole walking dead thing isn’t directly attributable to Jowan, since the plague is the work of a demon joined with Connor’s desire to save his father’s life. Indirectly the mess is Jowan’s fault, because there would be no demon if there were no poison and, as a result, no dying Arl. However, Jowan poisoning the Arl can, as described above, also be contributed to Loghain, who concocted the plan to eliminate an enemy and is using Jowan as his tool to do so.
But at the root of it all is Isolde. She knows her son is magic-cursed and refuses to lose him to the Circle. He inability to let her son go spawns the need for an apostate tutor, which opens the door for Loghain and allows Jowan to walk in, whose poisoning causes the demon to possess Connor which spawns the corpses.
Jowan’s failure and blame lies in not rejecting Loghain’s offer to posion the Arl. But the cards in his hand are lousy after what happened in the Circle Tower. He’s in trouble and desperate, and I’d argue that it’s human nature to dig yourself deeper into a hole trying to get out of one. Who as a child, teen or adult hasn’t faced a bad situation and tried to lie their way out of it, only to have those lies fold to even worsening consequences? It’s true that’s Jowan’s hole-digging is on a more grand scale than the previous situation, but he’s caught in the flux of other people’s misdeeds that only amplify his own problems.
Is he to blame for attempting to assassinate the Arl? Yes. But is he solely to blame or even mostly to blame for Redcliffe? I say no. Anyhow, it’s up to you how to deal with him.
Liked the article? Support us so we can bring you even more high quality content.
Page: 1 2
















11 comments
Comment by Darkrose on June 21, 2010 at 9:14 pm
I really think you're cutting Jowan too much slack. Yes, he gets dealt some bad cards, but 90% of his problems are due to poor choices on his part. Fall in love with an initiate? Instead of acknowledging that sadly, it's not going to happen, try to do the one thing guaranteed to make you a hunted fugitive–and make your girlfriend forswear her oaths, which always goes so well. Not a very strong mage? Try blood magic–and then lie to your Chantry girlfriend about it. Need help making your escape? Guilt-trip your best friend into helping you, even though it's likely to totally destroy her life. At every decision point up to Redcliffe, Jowan choses the option most likely to end in tragedy.
Comment by David on June 22, 2010 at 2:08 am
Jowan was just trying to help. Plain and simple. Things just turned for the worse very quickly. There was nothing he could do about it short of apologizing and trying to make things better despite all the glares. I frankly took pity on Jowan. Sure he screwed up and started dabbling in Blood Magic which he knew was forbidden. Had it knocked into his skull however many times. It's the big shiny button with the sign that says "Do not press". Eventually someone is going to come along and press it.
Can you really blame Isolde either for wanting to keep her child out of the Circle? It's her only son. If she allowed her son to be taken by the Circle, when is she ever going to see him again? Never? That sounds about right.
Jowan tried to do the right thing and in the slough of things just kind of slipped on the path and fell in a big pile of Darkspawn doodoo.
Sunrise, sunset.
Comment by garbaczd on June 22, 2010 at 2:11 am
Jowan was just trying to help. Plain and simple. Things just turned for the worse very quickly. There was nothing he could do about it short of apologizing and trying to make things better despite all the glares. I frankly took pity on Jowan. Sure he screwed up and started dabbling in Blood Magic which he knew was forbidden. Had it knocked into his skull however many times. It's the big shiny button with the sign that says "Do not press". Eventually someone is going to come along and press it.
Isolde was just trying to keep her child out of the Circle. If she allowed Connor to scamper around and go OOOO MAGIC!!, he would have been nabbed up quicker than 30 sovereigns laying around. Then when would she ever see her only son again.. never? That sounds about right.
I can't in the right mind blame Jowan 100%. He screwed up but, I think he tried to make right what he wronged and that's what matters.
Comment by garbaczd on June 22, 2010 at 2:12 am
Jowan was just trying to help. Plain and simple. Things just turned for the worse very quickly. There was nothing he could do about it short of apologizing and trying to make things better despite all the glares. I frankly took pity on Jowan. Sure he screwed up and started dabbling in Blood Magic which he knew was forbidden. Had it knocked into his skull however many times. It's the big shiny button with the sign that says "Do not press". Eventually someone is going to come along and press it.
Isolde was just trying to keep her child out of the Circle. If she allowed Connor to scamper around and go OOOO MAGIC!!, he would have been nabbed up quicker than 30 sovereigns laying around. Then when would she ever see her only son again.. never? That sounds about right.
Comment by Godzilla Guru on June 22, 2010 at 6:39 am
Jowan is not my favorite character, but I don’t hate him or think ill of him for the choices he made. Him falling in love is just as likely to happen to anyone. You could met someone who would be the last person you’d ever expect to fall in love with, and then one day you can’t think of anything more than being with that person. All his decisions are human decisions, whether good or bad; the same goes for Isolde (stuck-up noblewoman that she is), though her choices affected ALOT more people than Jowan’s. When a person is desperate to protect something he/she cherishes, logic and common sense get shoot out the window with a rocket launcher; that’s something I’v seen that applies to everybody, including critics.
Focusing back on this article, I’ve never really dwelled on just who truly is to blame for the events at Redcliffe primarily because I’ve never seen finger-pointing over a disaster to really help when it comes to actually resolving the issue. My attitude’s always been ‘save it for when we don’t have to deal with things trying to kill us’. Just saying…
Comment by stevegarbage on June 22, 2010 at 8:25 am
Forsaking love, even forbidden love, is not as easy as just "acknowledging that sadly it's not going to happen." Romeo and Juliet, Bastila Shan and Revan (to drop a different BioWare example), and even Eamon and Isolde (A Ferelden with an Orlesian, right after the war? Come on!) all happen despite them being against the rules and maybe everyone's better judgment.
And besides, if you were faced with being stripped of all emotions and being made Tranquil, might you not press yourself to try to escape it? Despite what Owain says, trainquility sounds like hell to me. *I'd* definitely concoct a plan to try to escape that life, no matter how stupid/dangerous/forbidden it might be.
As I've said throughout the two articles – I can't hold any of that or the actions he takes trying to change his lot in him against him. I pity him and his tragic life, if nothing else.
Comment by Darkrose on June 23, 2010 at 3:24 am
I actually question how deeply Jowan was in love, given that he lied to Lily about the one thing that would have really been a deal-breaker for her.
As far as being Tranquil, Irving says in one branch of the tree that if Jowan had come to him with his concerns before trying blood magic, he might have been able to help him. Here again, Jowan makes the worst possible choice.
I might be more sympathetic if Jowan's only problem was poor decision making skills. But he combines it with what, to me, reads as being a user. Notice how often he pulls the "if you were really my friend…" card. That hits too close to the "If you really loved me, you'd…" button for me. I guess my character's don't like being guilt tripped any more than I do.
I appreciate that you tried to make the case for him. I'm just still not convinced that Jowan's not a jerk.
Comment by Darkrose on June 23, 2010 at 3:48 am
These two actually said it better than I could. "Creepy Edward Cullen" is a bit redundant, but it does describe how I felt about Jowan:
Comment by Nic-V on June 25, 2010 at 5:17 pm
You can actually persuade Ban Teagan let Jowan go, so this article isn't 100% correct.
Comment by Godzilla Guru on June 26, 2010 at 6:00 am
How do you do that? Every time I tried to I couldn’t. Do I need higher persuasion?
Comment by LJW on June 27, 2010 at 5:43 am
I hate this topic because the whole Jowan's quest / story is bugged and can not be completed anyway.